ILEs: What's your MBTI Type?

[jason_m]

http://similarminds.com/jung.html

[Phaedrus]

These kind of polls are totally meaningless and does much more harm than good. Every single ILE in the whole world, without exceptions, is an ENTP in MBTT. The only thing that can be proven with such a poll is that people don't understand the types and that they look like idiots. It is of course stupid to believe that you can be some other type than ENTP if you really are an ILE.

[diljs]

These kind of polls are totally meaningless and does much more harm than good. Every single ILE in the whole world, without exceptions, is an ENTP in MBTT. The only thing that can be proven with such a poll is that people don't understand the types and that they look like idiots. It is of course stupid to believe that you can be some other type than ENTP if you really are an ILE.

Disagree. The MBTT's emphasis on the "social" definition of extraversion resulted in my always getting INTP in MBTT.

This was of course before I realized that I "need" people around me and enjoy them immensely and instead assumed "people don't like [my Ne], I must not like them either."

MBTT is about external behaviors, while socionics is about information processing. People can process things the same way yet act differently due to a fantastic array of environmental and internal variables.

[Phaedrus]

Disagree. The MBTT's emphasis on the "social" definition of extraversion resulted in my always getting INTP in MBTT.

That's a not too uncommon phenomenon, caused by the fact that you don't understand the meaning of the concept extraversion, which has the exact same meaning in MBTT as in Socionics. You confuse the symptoms of extraversion with extraversion itself. And you confuse your MBTI test result with your real type in MBTT too. They are not always the same thing.

An ENTP friend of mine also tested as INTP when he didn't understand the correct meaning of the words "extraversion" and "introversion". But the fact that he tested as INTP doesn't mean that he has ever been an INTP. He has always (since birth) been an ENTP in MBTT and an ILE in Socionics. And that is true of every other ILE/ENTP in the world too.

MBTT is about external behaviors, while socionics is about information processing.

No, that is totally false. Both MBTT and Socionics are about information processing, and both MBTT and Socionics are about external behaviours as well. There is no principal difference between these two theories in these respects.

People can process things the same way yet act differently due to a fantastic array of environmental and internal variables.

No, they can't. Not in the sense that is relevant to the types anyway.

[diljs]

I see what you're arguing, and yes I do agree that an ILE is innately an MBTT ENTP.

However my argument is that in practice, ILE's will get different results. Blah blah understanding of extraversion whatever, the way MBTI is worded generates different results for people who haven't researched what I consider a mostly useless theory.

[Phaedrus]

I see what you're arguing, and yes I do agree that an ILE is innately an MBTT ENTP.

So, you don't disagree. Why do you claim that you disagree when you clearly don't? Don't you understand your own claims?

However my argument is that in practice, ILE's will get different results.

Which is a TOTALLY irrelevant comment.

Blah blah understanding of extraversion whatever, the way MBTI is worded generates different results for people who haven't researched what I consider a mostly useless theory.

So you are an idiot who has an a opinion on a subject which you know nothing about? That's "explains" your idiotic behaviour, but it doesn't excuse it.

[diljs]

You're attacking me because you didn't understand what I said, that's insane.

What type are you, like a gamma NT or something?

[Phaedrus]

You're attacking me because you didn't understand what I said, that's insane.

No, I am attacking your false and idiotic beliefs. Get rid of them.

What type are you, like a gamma NT or something?

You know what type I am. I am the most hostile, aggressive, and critical INTp you can imagine.

[Logos]

You're attacking me because you didn't understand what I said, that's insane.

What type are you, like a gamma NT or something?

LSI. Accept it. It's a fact.

[diljs]

On second thought you've gotta be ISTj - my supervisory, lol. I can see why.

I'm gonna go do adult things now like have a casual conversation without getting angry and attacking people who don't fit my irrational framework of "logic".

Stay out of trouble, k?

[Phaedrus]

On second thought you've gotta be ISTj - my supervisory, lol. I can see why.

No, you can't. You are an idiot.

I'm gonna go do adult things now like have a casual conversation without getting angry and attacking people who don't fit my irrational framework of "logic".

If you don't accept the fact that I am an INTp, you don't deserve any respect from me. Deal with your idiocy.

[Logos]

No, you can't. You are an idiot.

If you don't accept the fact that I am an INTp, you don't deserve any respect from me. Deal with your idiocy.

Considering how little your respect is worth, he is better off without it.

[Phaedrus]

Considering how little your respect is worth, he is better off without it.

That's not my problem.

[diljs]

LSI. Accept it. It's a fact.

yep, agreed.

[Phaedrus]

yep, agreed.

No. How many idiots are there in this place? Is every Alpha an idiot?

[Wynch]

I'm an idiot.

[Socionics Is A Cult]

Is every Alpha an idiot?

Is every INTj a night owl?

[Phaedrus]

Is every INTj a night owl?

When will you accept that you are not an INTj, Subterranean? Do you think it is funny that you don't understand what type you are?

[Socionics Is A Cult]

When will you accept that you are not an INTj, Subterranean? Do you think it is funny that you don't understand what type you are?

Everyone knows from experience that you are wrong and you don't even know yourself.

[Phaedrus]

Everyone knows from experience that you are wrong and you don't even know yourself.

You are not an INTj.

[Socionics Is A Cult]

You are not an INTj.

What about INFj?

[jason_m]

These kind of polls are totally meaningless and does much more harm than good. Every single ILE in the whole world, without exceptions, is an ENTP in MBTT. The only thing that can be proven with such a poll is that people don't understand the types and that they look like idiots. It is of course stupid to believe that you can be some other type than ENTP if you really are an ILE.

What's your opinion on Albert Einstein, Phaedrus? Most Socionists consider him to be an ILE, while most MBTI enthusiasts consider him to be an INTP. What do you think?

Jason

[Phaedrus]

What's your opinion on Albert Einstein, Phaedrus? Most Socionists consider him to be an ILE, while most MBTI enthusiasts consider him to be an INTP. What do you think?

He was definitely one of these two types. I can accept him as ILE, but I don't find the evidence 100 % conclusive.

[Ezra]

Do you ever get bored of this shit, you bureaucratic fuckwit?

[angelalala]

this thread was hilarious to read, the ending was the best

fuckwit, bahahaha

(especially when you picture the guy in Ezra's photo delivering the last bit )

[aflyinge]

These kind of polls are totally meaningless and does much more harm than good. Every single ILE in the whole world, without exceptions, is an ENTP in MBTT. The only thing that can be proven with such a poll is that people don't understand the types and that they look like idiots. It is of course stupid to believe that you can be some other type than ENTP if you really are an ILE.

"People don't understand the types and that they look like idiots." The irony.

Have you heard of DCNH subtypes? Read the ILE-H description. Does that sound like ENTP to you?

[anotherperson]

"People don't understand the types and that they look like idiots." The irony.

Have you heard of DCNH subtypes? Read the ILE-H description. Does that sound like ENTP to you?

the post is from 2008, that users probably long gone by now. no use to waste your time